One of my Bible Class told me that she wouldn't be back to Bible Class because she was becoming a communicant member this weekend. I told her that it was great that she was doing that, but it wasn't graduation from Bible Class, and she was welcome to stay on for as long as she wanted.
The problem with the Presbyterian Church is that it is lost in the past, where children were now ment to see communion (we have no Sunday School on communion sunday), you don't go back to Bible Class when you become a member, you cannot move anything without having a meeting, you wear a dark suit, etc... My Dad once told me taht no one is as catholic as a presbyerian.
Of course this is not an absolute, and many comgregations are changing. The ones that don't change are primarily country congregations that do not have much new blood, so change is hard agains the generations of family tradition.
The big bug for me is the total alien coultur to outsiders. If some young people at work wanted to go to church, they would encounter things that they never have to in any other part of there lives:-
- Organ
- 20 min talk (at least)
- Choir
- pews
- dark suits (the only time they would see this, outside a morning service, is a funeral)
- faces like lurgan spades (again, outside the morning service, they can be found on politicians)
- Metrical Psalter (some of the language is ancient [For God the poor hears, and will not his prisoners contemn. Psalm 69v33], and rhyming insulting [Because the zeal did eat me up, which to thine house I bear; And the reproaches cast at thee, upon me fallen are. Psalm 69 v 9])
I often wonder if we are members of a living Church, or curators of a museums.
And all this before the theolgy.